ReviewProof ⚖

Why audit your reviews before spending on advertising?

By the Ingenious AI team · Published 14 November 2026 · Reviewed 14 November 2026

Run the free review audit See pricing · See a sample provenance report

Short answer

Because advertising buys scrutiny, not just traffic. Every click you pay for lands a stranger on your reviews with their guard up; if the profile they meet carries an incentive cluster, a gating-shaped distribution or a wall of unverifiable praise, the spend amplifies distrust at scale — and a campaign is also when platforms, competitors and journalists look hardest. The pre-campaign audit is one import cycle: read the signal lines, fix solicitation at source, publish the verified widget on the landing page the ads point to, and export the pack so the profile the campaign exposes is the profile you can document.

What is a pre-campaign review audit?

A pre-campaign review audit is the standard provenance audit run against a deadline: the launch of paid promotion. Its premise is that advertising changes the review profile's audience from organic visitors (who arrive with context) to paid strangers (who arrive with suspicion and a comparison tab), and its scope is the gap between the profile as it stands and the profile as that audience will test it — signals undisposed, widgets unpublished, landing-page claims broader than the certificates beneath them.

What the paid stranger does in the first minute

They do not read your reviews; they test them. The pattern is consistent: scan the average, open the most recent one-star, open the most detailed five-star, and ask the only question that matters — do these feel produced or found? Produced has a smell your audit can measure before the spend can: incentive language still quoting the old promotion, a distribution with no negatives worth the name, a burst aligned with your last agency's tenure. Found has a texture too: criticism kept and answered, linked proof one click away, specifics everywhere. The audit's job in the campaign window is to move every measurable marker from the first texture to the second while the audience is still small and the fixing is cheap.

Verified proof converts differently from raw stars because it answers the question a careful buyer actually asks: did these people really buy? The verified-experience widget only displays reviews that are both transaction-linked and in a kept or published moderation state, and every displayed review can be opened into its provenance certificate — source, date, transaction reference, moderation history. That is a stronger claim than a five-star average, and it is also a narrower one: UNLINKED reviews stay in your audit but never dress up as verified on your site. Honest narrowing is what makes the claim believable.

The landing page is part of the audit

Campaigns concentrate the placement doctrine to a single URL: the page the ads point to must carry the verification layer, because it is the page the paid stranger is standing on when the doubt fires. The verified widget belongs on that page, uncurated, its set exactly the rule's set; any review quote used in the ad creative itself should be a real, linked review whose certificate the landing page can produce (and the claim in the ad must survive comparison with the certificate's wording). Run the mechanical check the week before launch: click from the live ad to the live page to the least flattering displayed review to its certificate. If any hop fails, the campaign waits a day; a broken proof chain discovered by traffic is a story competitors retell.

ReviewProof's import is forgiving about format and strict about meaning. Column names are matched flexibly — body, review or text for the review itself; rating or stars; reviewer, author or name; a verified flag and a transaction reference when you hold them. Rows are capped per import by plan (500 on Free, 5,000 on Pro, 50,000 on Agency), which is generous for a single location's history. What the importer will not do is upgrade a review's status: a row that arrives without a transaction link is analysed fully and still labelled UNLINKED, because the label is the product.

Mistakes that undo the work

Launching first and auditing 'once the campaign settles' spends real money discovering what an afternoon would have shown. Cleaning the profile for the campaign by the old methods — a quiet burst of fresh positives from a vendor to dilute the cluster — converts a fixable history into a live violation dated during the campaign itself. And pointing ads at a testimonials page assembled by hand, while the audit's widget exists, advertises the unverifiable surface and wastes the provable one.

Plans decide how far the proof travels. Free covers one location with the full report, certificates and the widget. Pro ($29/month) adds the evidence export, full chain detail, AI reply drafts and the fraud graph across 3 locations — the tier most single businesses graduate to when a dispute or a due-diligence request arrives. Agency ($79/month) covers multi-location work at 50,000 reviews per import. None of that changes the free audit's completeness; it changes how much of the resulting evidence you can hand to other people, which is where proof starts earning its keep.

Worked example: a clinic pauses its launch by one week

A fictional worked example, written to show the numbers and the decisions in practice.

A dental clinic scheduled its first significant ad campaign, then ran the pre-campaign audit out of diligence. The import found 23 incentive rows from a whitening promotion the previous spring ('free whitening top-up, just leave us a review'), still sitting in the profile the ads would showcase, plus no verified widget on the campaign landing page at all. Launch moved one week: the promotion's solicitation was formally ended and logged, the 23 flagged internally as a set (kept, as always), the widget published on the landing page from the linked set, and the pack exported. The campaign then ran against a profile whose worst discoverable fact was a historical promotion the clinic had itself found, ended and documented — a fact no rival's screenshot could weaponise, because the record already contained it.

Your five-action checklist

  1. Run the full import audit before the campaign's creative is finalised
  2. Dispose of every signal line: fix solicitation, flag clusters, log decisions
  3. Publish the verified widget on the exact landing page the ads use
  4. Verify the click chain live: ad, page, worst displayed review, certificate
  5. Export the pre-campaign pack — the profile, documented, as the spend begins

Frequently asked questions

How long before launch should the audit run?

One full import cycle — allow a week. Most fixes are same-day (scripts, widgets); the week buys verification and the exported pack.

Should a campaign wait for a perfect profile?

No — it should wait for a documented one. A historical cluster found, flagged and ended by you is a defensible profile; an undisposed one is a liability with media spend behind it.

Can ad creative quote reviews?

Quote real reviews, ideally transaction-linked ones whose certificates the landing page can produce, and never edit a quote's meaning. The ad is a claim; the certificate is its evidence.

Does the audit belong on Free or Pro?

One location's audit and widget are complete on Free. The evidence export that documents the pre-campaign profile is a Pro feature — most campaign budgets justify it on the first dispute avoided.

Keep reading

Related guides from the ReviewProof library:

Start with the tool itself: open the free audit desk, see how ReviewProof works, compare Free, Pro and Agency plans, inspect the sample provenance report, or browse all ReviewProof guides.