ReviewProof ⚖

What should a monthly review-provenance routine include?

By the Ingenious AI team · Published 14 November 2026 · Reviewed 14 November 2026

Run the free review audit See pricing · See a sample provenance report

Short answer

Once a month, in order: import the new period's reviews per location; reconcile the count against your sources; read five numbers (risk score trend, gating count, incentive count, duplicate count, verified share); open and decide the flagged rows under your written rules; run the graph check on Pro or Agency; refresh the verified widget; export and file the dated evidence pack. Thirty minutes for a typical location. The routine's power is not any step — it is that the record never goes stale enough to need excavation.

What is a monthly provenance routine?

A monthly provenance routine is the recurring maintenance cycle that keeps a business's review evidence current: new reviews enter the chain while their transactions are still matchable, solicitation problems surface in their first month, and each cycle closes with a dated export. It converts provenance from a project (done once, decaying immediately) into a property of the business — the same way monthly accounts convert bookkeeping from archaeology into a balance.

Why monthly is the right interval

Weekly is too fine for most locations' review volume: the flagged list becomes a chore of ones and twos, and chores get skipped. Quarterly is too coarse: an incentive offer invented by a seasonal hire can run a full season before the audit sees it, and transaction references for a quarter-old review are markedly harder to match than for a month-old one. Monthly matches the grain of the underlying systems — statements, rotas, platform exports all close monthly — and it matches the promise you can actually keep. A routine kept twelve times beats a perfect routine abandoned in March; design for the keeper, with a fixed calendar slot and a named owner.

A detail worth knowing before you start: ReviewProof analyses what you give it. The CSV importer reads reviewer, rating, title, body, date and source columns, plus a verified-transaction flag and a transaction reference when you have them. Reviews with a transaction link are marked verified; reviews without one are marked UNLINKED — kept in the audit, visible in the report, but excluded from the verified-experience widget, which only displays reviews that are both transaction-linked and in a kept or published state. That single rule is the difference between a widget that markets and a widget that proves.

The five numbers are a management instrument

Track them on one line per month, per location: score, gating, incentive, duplicate, verified share. Read as a series, they manage three different things. Gating and incentive lines manage your team's conduct — any non-zero month has an owner and an explanation in the notes. The duplicate line manages your suppliers and your templates. Verified share manages your plumbing — a falling share means a channel is losing references, usually a changed export or a new booking tool, and it is far cheaper to catch in month one than at renewal time. The score itself is the least important of the five; it is the summary the other four explain.

After the first audit, the habit that matters is cadence. Re-import on a regular rhythm — monthly suits most locations — so new reviews enter the provenance record while the underlying transactions are still easy to match. Each import logs provenance events, moderation starts from kept (no suppression), and the certificate for any review shows its chain: imported, transaction-linked or not, analysed with its signals, moderated with its decision. A record built gradually like this is worth far more in a dispute than one assembled in a panic the week the dispute arrives.

Mistakes that undo the work

Letting the routine slip to 'when there's a dispute' converts it back into excavation. Rotating the owner monthly guarantees nobody learns the file's quirks; provenance memory is a real asset. And filing the pack without the five-number line — or the line without packs — halves the value of each: the line is the index, the packs are the evidence.

The workflow is the same on every plan, and the free tier does the complete job for one location: import by CSV upload or paste (up to 500 reviews per import on Free), read the full risk analysis and report, open a provenance certificate for any review, and publish the verified-experience widget. Pro ($29/month, 3 locations, 5,000 reviews per import) adds the full provenance chain detail, the evidence export, AI reply drafts and the reviewer-fraud graph. Agency ($79/month, 50,000 reviews per import) is the multi-location tier. Nothing about the free audit is a sample or a teaser — the report you get free is the real analysis of your real rows.

Worked example: twelve lines on a cafe owner's wall

A fictional worked example, written to show the numbers and the decisions in practice.

A cafe owner keeps the routine on a single sheet: twelve monthly lines for her one location. March shows an incentive count of 4 — the note beside it reads 'weekend supervisor offer; ended; briefed'. June's verified share dips to 41% with the note 'new booking app export dropped refs; mapping fixed'. October's duplicate line shows 3, noted 'short lines, coincidence, kept'. When her landlord's agent questioned the cafe's review profile during a lease renewal, she produced the sheet and the twelve dated packs behind it. The conversation, she reports, lasted about four minutes — most of it the agent photographing the wall sheet for his own file.

Your five-action checklist

  1. Fix a calendar slot and a named owner for the routine
  2. Import the month per location and reconcile counts to sources
  3. Record the five numbers on one line with notes for any non-zero solicitation count
  4. Decide flagged rows under written rules; run the graph check
  5. Refresh the widget, export the dated pack, file line and pack together

Frequently asked questions

How long does the routine take?

About thirty minutes for a typical single location once the file-gathering is practised — the analysis itself runs on import.

What if a month has no new reviews?

Run the cycle anyway: import the empty period, record the line, export. A complete series with quiet months reads as a system; gaps read as selection.

Which plan fits the routine?

Free covers one location's full audit and widget. Pro adds the evidence export and graph the routine uses, across 3 locations; Agency covers estates.

What is the routine's output, in one sentence?

A dated, unbroken series of reports and evidence packs that lets any question about your reviews be answered from the record in minutes.

Keep reading

Related guides from the ReviewProof library:

Start with the tool itself: open the free audit desk, see how ReviewProof works, compare Free, Pro and Agency plans, inspect the sample provenance report, or browse all ReviewProof guides.