What counts as an incentivised review?
By the Ingenious AI team · Published 14 November 2026 · Reviewed 14 November 2026
Run the free review audit See pricing · See a sample provenance report
Short answer
A review is incentivised when something of value — a discount, coupon, gift card, free item, voucher, cashback or reward points — is offered or given in connection with writing it, above all when the value depends on a positive review. ReviewProof scans imported review text for incentive markers and weights them at 1.0 in the risk score, joint-heaviest of all signals, because the FTC fake-review rule bans buying sentiment outright.
What is an incentivised review?
An incentivised review is a review written in exchange for value. The incentive may be explicit ('20% off for a five-star review') or softer (a free dessert handed over with the review page open), and the reviewer often discloses it innocently in the text itself: 'they gave me a voucher', 'received a free item'. The FTC rule (16 CFR Part 465) prohibits providing incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment, and platforms treat undisclosed incentivised reviews as fake.
The words reviewers leave behind
Businesses rarely document their own offers, but reviewers do. The imported text is full of receipts: mentions of discounts, coupons, gift cards, free items, refunds and reward points, phrases like 'in exchange for a review' or 'they offered me'. ReviewProof's incentive patterns match exactly this vocabulary, which is why an audit of your own file is so revealing — a promotion invented by one staff member, never written down anywhere, will still surface in row after row of customer wording. Nine rows quoting the same offer is not nine coincidences; it is a policy you did not know you had.
ReviewProof computes every signal from the rows you import, never from a reputation guess about your business. The risk score is 100 × (gating × 1.0 + incentive × 1.0 + duplicate × 0.8 + AI-signal × 0.6) ÷ (2.6 × number of reviews), plus 15 points when a burst is detected, capped at 100. Each flagged review in the report names the imported row that triggered the signal, so a human can open that row, read it in context, and decide. The product labels these patterns signals for human review, not verdicts — and that restraint is deliberate, because a heuristic that overclaims would be its own kind of false evidence.
Loyalty is not an incentive — until it touches the review
Ordinary loyalty rewards, given for custom and not for commentary, sit outside the problem. The line is crossed at the junction: value connected to writing, posting, or the content of a review. A free coffee for joining a loyalty scheme is marketing; a free coffee when the review posts is an incentivised review; a free coffee for a five-star review is buying sentiment, the clearest violation in the rule. Staff training should draw the line at the junction in plain words, and the monthly audit should check that review text has stopped mentioning offers — the incentive count is the training's report card.
After the first audit, the habit that matters is cadence. Re-import on a regular rhythm — monthly suits most locations — so new reviews enter the provenance record while the underlying transactions are still easy to match. Each import logs provenance events, moderation starts from kept (no suppression), and the certificate for any review shows its chain: imported, transaction-linked or not, analysed with its signals, moderated with its decision. A record built gradually like this is worth far more in a dispute than one assembled in a panic the week the dispute arrives.
Mistakes that undo the work
The worst response is asking incentivised reviewers to edit out the mention: the review stays bought, the evidence is tampered with, and the chain of custody is broken. Second is assuming a small incentive is harmless — the rule cares about the connection to sentiment, not the size of the voucher. Third is running staff competitions on review counts, which manufactures incentives one removed: the pressure lands on customers whether or not money changes hands at the till.
Two design choices keep the detection honest. First, nothing is scored until you import it: there is no scraping of your public profiles and no third-party score blended in. Second, the weights reflect what the FTC fake-review rule (16 CFR Part 465) actually prohibits — how a review was solicited weighs heaviest (gating and incentive markers at 1.0 each), while wording patterns weigh less (duplicates 0.8, AI-generation patterns 0.6). A burst of same-day reviews adds a flat 15 points because timing is visible in the dates you supply. You can reproduce every number in the report from your own file, which is exactly the point.
Worked example: a cafe that found a promotion it never approved
A fictional worked example, written to show the numbers and the decisions in practice.
A cafe imported 142 reviews and saw an incentive count of 13, all dated within five weeks, all mentioning a free drink. A weekend supervisor had invented the offer to lift the rating before a local guide's deadline. The owner kept every row (deleting them would have been suppression), flagged them internally with the reason logged in the provenance chain, ended the offer the same day, and briefed every shift on the junction rule: rewards for custom, never for commentary. The next two monthly imports showed incentive counts of zero — a correction visible in the record, which is the strongest thing the cafe could later show anyone.
Your five-action checklist
- Search your imported reviews for the incentive count and read every flagged row
- Ask staff directly whether any offer is attached to reviews, on any shift
- End every offer connected to writing, posting or praising a review
- Brief the junction rule: rewards for custom, never for commentary
- Re-import monthly and confirm the incentive count stays at zero
Frequently asked questions
Is any discount for reviewers illegal?
Value offered in connection with a review — and above all value conditioned on positive sentiment — is prohibited under the FTC fake-review rule. General loyalty rewards unconnected to reviews are a different matter.
What if the customer mentions an old, unrelated offer?
Read the row in context; signals shortlist, humans decide. If the offer genuinely had no connection to the review, note that decision in the moderation record.
Why does ReviewProof weight incentives so heavily?
At 1.0, joint with gating, because how a review was bought goes to the core of the FTC rule — it describes solicitation, not just suspicious wording.
Should incentivised reviews be removed?
Keep them in the audit, flagged internally with the reason logged. Removing them silently is suppression and destroys the evidence that you found and fixed the practice.
Keep reading
Related guides from the ReviewProof library:
- How can you prove a review is real?
- How do you detect fake reviews in your own profile?
- What is review gating, and how do you stop doing it?
- What does duplicate review text tell you?
- What is a review burst, and when is it innocent?
- Can you tell if a review was written by AI?
- How is the ReviewProof risk score calculated?
Start with the tool itself: open the free audit desk, see how ReviewProof works, compare Free, Pro and Agency plans, inspect the sample provenance report, or browse all ReviewProof guides.